The recruiter sounds thrilled, and you feel pressure to respond to a job offer right now. So you say “Great, I accept,” and that one sentence can cost you more than any answer you gave in the interview.
Quick answer: To respond to a job offer, thank them, say you’re excited, and ask for 48 hours to review the full package. Then research your number, make one counter slightly above your target, and stop talking. A short review window is routine, and a phone call keeps the tone warm.
Should you accept a job offer on the spot?
No. Even when you love the role, accept nothing until you’ve seen the full package in writing. The moment you say yes, the negotiation is over, and you can’t reopen it.
However, “don’t accept on the spot” doesn’t mean “play hard to get.” You can sound grateful and still buy yourself time. In fact, the pause itself changes the dynamic, because it tells them you treat this as a decision, not a favor.
How long can you take to respond to a job offer?
Ask for 48 hours. A few days is a normal request, and some employers will give you a week. Whatever you ask for, know your reason before you call.
Harvard’s career services recommends asking for more decision time by phone or video, not email, and restating your interest in the role while you do. That advice holds for experienced hires too. A live call lets them hear the enthusiasm, which makes the request easy to grant.
Here’s the line:
“Thank you, I’m really excited about this. I’d like 48 hours to review the full package, and I’ll come back to you by Thursday.”
Name the day. Then send a two-line email afterward that confirms it in writing.
How do you pick your number before you counter?
Use data, not a feeling. Check Levels.fyi, Glassdoor and Blind for the role, level and location. A counter without data is a wish, while a counter with data is a case.
Then follow three rules:
- Pick one number. If you tell them a floor early and a different figure later, they’ll split the difference and call it generous. One number, one anchor.
- Ask slightly above your target. If you want 102, ask for 103. You land the number you wanted, and they never had to talk you down to it.
- Anchor on base. Base is what every future raise compounds on. A one-time sign-on doesn’t reset your floor.
The math shows why. Say your base starts $10,000 higher and you get 3% raises each year. Over five years that gap adds up to about $53,000 in base pay alone, before bonus or retirement match. You aren’t negotiating this year’s salary. You’re setting the floor for everything after it.
What do you say when you make the counter?
Keep it short, polite and firm:
“Based on my research and the scope of this role, I’m looking for $X in base salary. I’m flexible on how we get there.”
Add one line about why you fit this specific role. One. Then stop talking. Most people fill the silence by walking back what they just said, and that’s where the money leaks out.
When I edit a client’s counter-offer email, the first thing I cut is the deference. Phrases like “I wanted to ask,” “I’m truly grateful” and “I’ll do whatever it takes” sound kind, but they hand over your advantage. They made you an offer for your services. You don’t need permission to price them.
What if the answer on base is no?
Move to the other levers. When base hits a ceiling, try the signing bonus. After that, try equity, PTO, start date, remote flexibility and title. There’s almost always somewhere to go, and our guide to what to negotiate besides salary walks through the order.
One tip: don’t name the signing bonus in your opening ask, even if you expect to land there. Let them counter first, then bring it in as the bridge. Otherwise they’ll latch onto it and stop moving on base.
If you haven’t researched your range yet, start with what to say when a recruiter asks about salary expectations, because that first answer sets the anchor you’re countering against. And if you’re unsure the role is even worth the fight, build the other scorecard first.
FAQ
Is it rude to ask for time before you accept a job offer?
No. Asking for more time is one of the most common things candidates negotiate, and a warm tone makes it easy to grant.
Can an employer pull an offer if you counter?
It’s uncommon when you stay polite and make a researched ask, though nothing is guaranteed. If a company drops an offer over one respectful counter, that tells you how it would treat you on the job.
Should you respond to a job offer by email or by phone?
Use the phone to ask for time and to make the counter, then confirm the details in writing. Email alone invites a written no.
How far above your target should you counter?
Slightly. Ask for a figure just above what you’d happily accept, so your real target reads as a win for both sides.
What to do next
If you want to know what a slow search is costing you before the offer even arrives, run the job search cost assessment. It takes ninety seconds and gives you a monthly dollar figure.
If you’re sitting on more than one offer, read How to Handle Multiple Job Offers Without Blowing It next.
If you’d rather have someone look at your offer with you and tell you exactly what to say, book a free strategy call.